It’s spring (almost), and a young (?) man’s dreams turn to ….

… data. I figure that if I am going to continue to do some racing then I need to get a bit more serious, actually do a training regimen, and then I might need some data. And then it gets down to a question of what data and which data collection device. Ugh!

Data collectionI had been ignoring the issue for a number of reasons.

  • Holding off on spending $$$ until the taxman has come and gone (hopefully with no more of our $$$).
  • Waiting to get over my loathing of the PowerTap after dealing with The Wife’s early Pro model which has lots of warts.
  • Waiting to see how serious I will be at racing.
  • I am not big on collecting new toys.

But then last week ‘Uncle REI’ informed me of my yearly rebate, err, dividend which is a bit on the high side due to a number of purchases made for work.  REI does not carry power devices, except the Polar, but they do have the Garmin’s (though they do not quality for the 20% off one item deal).  Hmmmm, says I.  That overcomes the first reason.  OK, need some time to think this over.  It would seem silly to get a Garmin if I were to get a PowerTap soon; no reason to lug both around.   And though the new Garmin 705 works with the SRM it does not work with the PowerTap (PowerTap uses the early ANT protocol, not ANT+), so there is no way to get all the information collected in one device.   And until the SRM comes off patent and inexpensive 3rd party knock-offs come out I will not go down that path.  What to do, what to do?

While musing on it over the weekend I joined up for the Saturday PenVelo ride (thanks folks) and did a bit of an survey.  Funny it was an even split among the participants, 2 for the PowerTap, 2 for the Garmin, the rest (20+) undecided (of course the real zealots were at Merco).   So for now the data I collect will be speed and cadence (average and max) and will continue to wonder what I am missing, other than frustration.

I think you can put together a good training program if you can track HR and cadence. Those are the things my program is based upon.

beth - he’s already gone to the dark (carbon) side. Not that I can talk….but I love my ’steel is real’ racer better than my carbon wonder.

Chris - thanks for the input. Still musing. If I were to decide today it would be the Garmin Edge so I could try to correlate HR with cadence and topography. But, that might change by tomorrow.

Beth - as Ms C says I have carbon. What she did not remind you of was that it is the bike (Colnago) I was given last year by my boss (it was his brother’s). The other 3 bikes are steel.

twinkiepatissier

twinkiepatissier’s avatar

this is just an insider information… but someone that i know has a carbon lust… it’s perfectly ok to have a carbon this-n-that.

i think i am gonna score more seirus glove liners with my rei dividend.

Twinkie - hmmm, so someone you know (*cough* Beth *cough*) has gotten bit by the carbon bug? Is this person planning on scratching that itch?

Still not sure where the REI dividend will go. Ideas are swirling round and round.

:-) gadgets gadgets….i have the ibike, and i’m pretty impressed. Assuming you are enough of a techie/geek to calibrate it and make sure you are measuring what you think you are, it’s come a long way in the past 18 months. Cheaper than a SRM, more than a garmin (if you get the wireless HR integrated mount), gives all the normal data +power. It also gives interesting information on wind speed, grade of climb, etc. I find it pretty fun, but that’s becuase it has MEMS inside, and MEMS are what I work on in my other life.

Anyway…food for thought.

Taxes….let’s just not go there. No new gadgets for me for awhile…and no new wheelset either :-(. bummer.

Doc Kim - we keep looking at the iBike. One guy from my team rode with both an iBike and a Polar power meter at Merco to get a comparison. One of Ms. C’s former co-workers has an iBike and an SRM and has compared those (favorably). Definitely on the radar map here.

I will get serious about taxes in a week or so; with the relatively new rules that allow some investment vehicles to amend their data up to mid-March it becomes folly to try to get the numbers massaged before then. Until then, we have no real idea of what the tax man will reap.

lust is far removed. i lust for fabian cancellera, not boys i have actually gone on dates with. much the same with carbon.

Beth - Fabian? I thought you went for the Eastern European look? Carbon bikes are OK, but a sweet bike made of lightweight steel is even better in my opinion.

I spent my REI dividend on radios for the race. and although radios were on the exclusion list (like garmin) they still gave me the 20% off.

VeloGirl - Ahh, so that is where those spiffy radio you carried came from. You are luckier than I; I tried to see if I could get the discount, especially since the exclusion states “GPS receiver” and their categorization of the Edge is as “Bike Computer”. But they were not buying that argument; no discount.